Just as I feared when I made the purchase the bottle of 2009 Vigneto Reiné Mataòssu (Lumassina) from Punta Crena was not showing nearly as well as the two bottles of 2008 I had sipped this past spring. I am hoping that it was a combination of the wine's relative youth and the recent ocean voyage that resulted in the disappointing tasting - oh, for just one more bottle of 2008. The bottom line is that the 2007 Stadlmann Zierfandler Mandel Höh bested the 2009 Vigneto Reiné Mataòssu hands down late last week.
Here is what I was expecting based on my tasting of several bottles of the 2008 vintage last spring:
Straw colored with a definite greenish cast, the nose is loaded with yellow fruit with notes of flowers and clover honey. This is definitely a medium weight wine with an unusual structure that starts off with a yellow fruit richness compatible with its weight, but then moves into major amounts of citrus, from lemon to lemon peel, and then to grapefruit peel with the richness still at the core. Even with all of this citrus the Punta Cerna Mataòssu is about as far removed as you can get from those light-bodied wines that are all acid and slate. Subsequent sips revealed the long, long finish with pleasant notes of sea salt and citrus peel that seemed to linger on the tongue forever. - a different type of 'richness' indeed.
The nose on the 2009 was very, very shy, and even before I consulted my earlier notes, I didn't take this as a good sign. I opened and poured both the well-chilled wines at roughly the same time, so I let the glasses sit covered, at room temperature for about 40 minutes before approaching the Punta Crena again, and it was still shy. At best that evening and the next I got a modicum of citrus on the nose, and a hint of minerals, but little else - no honey or flowers. It was crisp and citrusy - mainly lemon - with grapefruit peel and slate at the core on the palate. The core of yellow fruit richness was not present as it was in the 2008, and this version struggled to reach middle weight and had a very short finish sans salt. It was more like the typical Ligurian indigenous whites, one dimensional citrus bombs. I will give it another chance later in the year with the hopes of it capturing even a fraction of the delight I received in the 2008.
Even in its well chilled state, one whiff of the Stadlmann Zierfandler Mandel Höh 2007 triggered the memory of the body and complex palate from two previous bottles and suggested it was going to blow away the Punta Crena 2009...